MAIN « newer: "It lives!"
"The Spread of Weighted Lists": older »  
Sorting the mess in tags sorting the mess in the Net
| 02/02 | Filed under: Blogging Interaction

repeating tagsYet another article (in Wired this time) about tags and folksonomies and yet another article that fails to mention any potential problems associated with a taxonomy uncontrolled by people (a folksonomy).
Tags work very well on a personal basis, you tag the data that's of interest to you, da_way-youWant. But what happens when the sites need to harvest the potential of those tags to empower the users?

The article states: We know that Flickr hosts 23,081 images tagged with "cat" or "cats" and only 17,463 with "dog" or "dogs". and the list of popular tags on del.icio.us reveals, for example, "blog, blogging, blogs" and "photo, photography, photos".

Take an end-user (that might also be using the service to save his bookmarks, but not necessarily) looking to use del.icio.us or flickr to find good links/pics on a given subject (their being-saved-here implying a certain degree usefulness --or prettiness in the case of Flickr-- as opposed to Technorati); he is presented with duplicate keywords... Moreover, he cannot splice (is it the right word?) those keywords to find links tagged by a selection of keywords. He cannot refine his search. Should he go back to Google?

Tagging systems don't seem to be future-proof yet. Aren't sites like Google Suggest (widget that could be reused and enhanced to show, for similarly spelled tags, the recommended spell) and the rudimentary del.icio.us tag stemmer proofs that we already have a big mess and are in the process of creating another one in parallel?
I sure do hope that there is more to tags than pretty weighted lists and a rehash of the meta keywords tag.

Comments
Post a comment (a href, b, br, p, strong, em, ul, li, blockquote)













5 most recent entries
15/03 | Hitotoki spreading! | Japan
If you haven't visited our project hitotoki.org recently, then now is the time. The small literary website building an emotional map of Tokyo is growing faster than we ever imagined,...
15/03 | Best anime of 2008 | Japan
Bokurano Without a doubt!! Great story, great character dvpt, no moe BS. But careful though, it's gloomy!! gloo-my!! As the series progresses, you discover all the hardships that those kids... details...
15/03 | Restarting? | Blogging
OK, I deleted all my comments by mistakes months ago and was hoping to be able to restore everything; but as this is going nowhere and new entries are piling...
09/09 | Thoughts on Casio's W53CA for AU | Interaction Japan Mobility
After my recent announce of the new AU Summer Collection, I had to wait a couple months before the official release of the Casio W53CA phone. I got the phone... details...
08/09 | Help Find Steve Fossett | Mobility Personal
So I've spent the past couple hours helping find Steve Fossett. I have become a Mechanical Turk for Amazon and have been reviewing satellite imagery of the area where Steve... details...
> Main Page

^ Back to Top ^